17 Popular Mustards, Ranked Worst To Best
Josh Forden/Shutterstock By Amanda Maida/Updated: Jan. 26, 2023 4:45 pm EST
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links. People all over the world love to pair condiments with food because they provide an extra touch that can turn a boring meal into a tasty and more appealing one. There are condiments for all different kinds of tastes, but mustard is one for those who prefer a tangy zip. And it’s not just useful for slathering on a hamburger bun or zig-zagging across a hot dog — mustard is extremely versatile and is ideal in dressings and vinaigrettes, glazes, and to add depth to dishes such as deviled eggs and creamy potato salad.
The main ingredient is grounded seeds from the mustard plant, which come in brown, white, and yellow, giving each type its distinct appearance. They are then processed with vinegar (in yellow) or verjuice (in Dijon), to name just two methods. Honey mustard is another popular form, but it can be packed with sugar, which means higher calories and less of a bite. While mustard doesn’t get all the love that ketchup and mayonnaise do, that doesn’t mean there aren’t plenty of delicious options to choose from so that everyone is sure to find a taste that they like.
- Daily Chef Organic Yellow Mustard
Sam’s Club
Daily Chef is a brand that is a part of Member’s Mark, which is owned by Sam’s Club. While the warehouse club store is well known for several delectable treats from their own brands, this organic yellow mustard falls flat.
There are no strange ingredients used; all are within the scope of a regular yellow mustard recipe such as spices like paprika and turmeric. However, reviewer Wizhat2 gave it a one-star rating. They claim to have tried various mustards before, including generic, and have concluded that this one has an “odd flavor.” But Sam’s Club itself isn’t a write-off when it comes to purchasing large quantities of mustard. Consumers can purchase other name brands in large two-pack bottles, a jug that weighs over 6 pounds, and a 500-count box of individual packets. Even if you have room left over in one of their oversized shopping carts, this mustard can be left on one of the seemingly endless store shelves.
- Trader Joe’s Dijon Mustard
Dijon mustard came to be in France in the 18th century and has been a delicacy in the country ever since. Named for the town of Dijon, this mustard has a distinct flavor profile from the standard American yellow mustard. Dijon uses both black and brown mustard seeds, but the most significant difference is that it doesn’t traditionally use vinegar. Instead, Dijon is made with verjuice, the liquid of unripened grapes, which gives it a smooth flavor, velvety texture, and thickened consistency. White wine is a popular substitute for verjuice, while some recipes use a mix of vinegar and spices.
Trader Joe’s has their own version of Dijon mustard, but unfortunately it’s not that much to be desired. The primary complaint is that it’s much too strong. A reviewer named Carol on Traderjoesreviews.com complains that it’s “like eating wasabi straight up,” a sentiment echoed by others on the site. Another reviewer claims that it gave them “stomach problems after eating it just once.”
- Market Pantry Spicy Brown Mustard
Target
Spicy brown mustard gets its bite by soaking the mustard seeds in less vinegar during the preparation process. This means that the mustard seeds (brown and black, normally) are truer to their original taste. A variety of spices, such as cinnamon or nutmeg, can be used for a more robust flavor, but that doesn’t seem to be the case for the Target-brand Market Pantry spicy brown mustard which falls short in the taste department.
The mustard is labeled as “zesty deli style,” which is another way to indicate the rich spiciness. None of the standard ingredients stand out that would lead one to believe this has an off taste, though one addition is simply labelled as “spices” which is obviously quite vague. Onion powder is another ingredient that might raise an eyebrow, but it still doesn’t pinpoint whatever the exact problem is. According to a reviewer on Target’s website, the “flavor is too harsh” and it tasted more like horseradish. Another notes that it’s “nothing special.” Have no fear, there are other spicy brown varieties on this list that stay true to the traditional zing.
- Annie’s Organic Yellow Mustard
Annie’s is a brand that is well-appreciated for their commitment to nurturing a healthy planet and healthy diets with their line of organic food products, which include vegan and gluten-free options. You may have noticed their macaroni and cheese, snacks, and baking items on your local grocery store shelves, but did you know that they produce dressings and condiments too? Annie’s currently offers four varieties of mustard, including a classic yellow.
They claim that their product is free from artificial flavorings and colors, and they strictly use all organic ingredients. So far, so good. While there are plenty of favorable consumer reviews for the mustard, it also has some detractors. KarinaGof on iHerb.com writes that it tastes sour, and several others agree on the weird taste. Another iHerb customer claims that it might just be “tinted mayonnaise without taste.” For this organic yellow mustard, it’s best not to let the positive reviews sway you until you try it for yourself.
- Burman’s Spicy Brown Mustard
Aldi is a unique grocery store that began in Germany and has since spread worldwide. It first came here in 1976 and now has a dedicated Stateside following. Fans appreciate the chain’s low prices for staple foods like meats, breads, and frozen items. You won’t normally find too many name-brand products on their shelves, as Aldi’s inventory is stocked with over 90% of their own private brands such as Burman’s which specializes in condiments.
Their spicy brown mustard currently costs only $0.99, according to Instacart. It’s made with the usual distilled vinegar, mustard seeds, and spices found in any regular mustard, so what could be so wrong? Actually, not much. As far as discount mustards go, Aldi’s Burman’s brand isn’t too bad. Fooducate gives it an “A” rating, but watch out for 80 milligrams of sodium, which is slightly higher per serving (one teaspoon) compared to other brands. For that reason, we placed this in the middle of our list.
- Great Value Yellow Mustard
Great Value is the Walmart generic brand name. They have pretty much every kind of product you can think of, including home goods, toiletries, cleaning supplies, and groceries. Their foods are hit-or-miss, meaning that sometimes one of their generic products is tasty but other times it might be better to spend a little extra for the name brand and the quality that comes with it. That being said, one Great Value food product you should consider trying is their yellow mustard.
Yes, seriously! According to Walmart’s website, there’s nothing abnormal within the ingredients — mustard seed, vinegar, water, and some spices. There are zero calories and 60 milligrams of sodium per teaspoon, which is standard when it comes to the tangy condiment. Plus, a 20-ounce bottle will set you back a mere dollar. Now that’s a deal! Reviewer Marbelva claims that Great Value yellow mustard is “as good as French’s.” Over on Influenster, the reviews are also positive with Teresa G. suggesting it has the “same taste as name brands.” All in all, don’t devalue Great Value, at least when it comes to mustard.
- Heinz 100% Natural Yellow Mustard
Heinz is a beloved homegrown condiment company that dates back to 1869. Most famous for their tomato ketchup, they’ve grown into a world-leader in condiments ranging from pickles, mayonnaise, gravy, vinegar, and most recently a line of unique mixed sauces. When it comes to basic mustard, Heinz 100% natural yellow mustard is one of the very best. It’s a classic! Made with all natural ingredients, the strikingly bright yellow condiment provides a burst of zesty zing to your favorite meats, sandwiches, and sauces. And the best part? Zero calories, zero sugar, and zero sodium.
Influenster reviews are overwhelmingly positive with a near perfect rating based on over 900 reviews. It’s also listed as their second choice of mustards overall. Consumer Maika R. writes that this mustard matches the high quality that one would expect from Heinz food products. Melissa C. claims that “you can not go wrong” with Heinz’s yellow mustard, especially for the affordable price.
- Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard
For the very best in spicy brown mustard zest, Gulden’s is the one to choose. Produced with organic vinegar, #1 grade mustard seeds, and an aromatic array of spices, Gulden’s Spicy Brown mustard is difficult to beat. Not only does it use fine, organic ingredients, it also contains less sodium than many of its competitors (just 50 milligrams per teaspoon).
While Influenster ranks it seventh on their mustard list, consumers over there give it a strong 4.8 out of 5-star rating. For reviewer Laura K., it’s the “only mustard” they buy. Maria V. suggests using it in vegetable soup to “kick up the flavor,” as well as adding some to egg dishes and squeezed on top of hot dogs. Various other reviews state that Gulden’s isn’t too spicy, which can make it appealing to most taste buds, and thus ranks it as one of the leading mustards that is currently available.
- French’s Classic Yellow Mustard
Mustard in its natural form is derived from the mustard seed, which can be beneficial for your health. However, in processed condiment form, it’s French’s Classic Yellow that is the most beneficial on burgers and hot dogs. And classic it is, ever since French’s debuted at the 1904 World’s Fair. It quickly became an American favorite, whether you were at a baseball game or a local backyard barbecue. Although they provide a plethora of condiments and other food products including Crispy Fried Onions and chili seasonings, the name French’s has become synonymous with yellow mustard.
It holds a steady 4.9 out of 5-rating with 97% of reviewers recommending the bright yellow product, via McCormick’s website. Influenster ranks it as their top mustard (with over 7,000 consumer reviews) and rightfully so. Ginger L. suggests adding it to chicken and egg salads, and praises the top quality for the value. Erin H. calls it the “best yellow mustard out there” and contends that it’s the only one to buy, claiming that it tastes better than store-branded varieties. They also rave that the consistency is just right and the squeeze bottle provides the perfect portion, along with the ideal tang, of course. French’s mustard just can’t be beat.
17 Popular Mustards, Ranked Worst To Best
Josh Forden/Shutterstock
By Amanda Maida/Updated: Jan. 26, 2023 4:45 pm EST
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links. People all over the world love to pair condiments with food because they provide an extra touch that can turn a boring meal into a tasty and more appealing one. There are condiments for all different kinds of tastes, but mustard is one for those who prefer a tangy zip. And it’s not just useful for slathering on a hamburger bun or zig-zagging across a hot dog — mustard is extremely versatile and is ideal in dressings and vinaigrettes, glazes, and to add depth to dishes such as deviled eggs and creamy potato salad.
The main ingredient is grounded seeds from the mustard plant, which come in brown, white, and yellow, giving each type its distinct appearance. They are then processed with vinegar (in yellow) or verjuice (in Dijon), to name just two methods. Honey mustard is another popular form, but it can be packed with sugar, which means higher calories and less of a bite. While mustard doesn’t get all the love that ketchup and mayonnaise do, that doesn’t mean there aren’t plenty of delicious options to choose from so that everyone is sure to find a taste that they like.
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
The main ingredient is grounded seeds from the mustard plant, which come in brown, white, and yellow, giving each type its distinct appearance. They are then processed with vinegar (in yellow) or verjuice (in Dijon), to name just two methods. Honey mustard is another popular form, but it can be packed with sugar, which means higher calories and less of a bite.
While mustard doesn’t get all the love that ketchup and mayonnaise do, that doesn’t mean there aren’t plenty of delicious options to choose from so that everyone is sure to find a taste that they like.
17. Daily Chef Organic Yellow Mustard
Sam’s Club
Daily Chef is a brand that is a part of Member’s Mark, which is owned by Sam’s Club. While the warehouse club store is well known for several delectable treats from their own brands, this organic yellow mustard falls flat.
There are no strange ingredients used; all are within the scope of a regular yellow mustard recipe such as spices like paprika and turmeric. However, reviewer Wizhat2 gave it a one-star rating. They claim to have tried various mustards before, including generic, and have concluded that this one has an “odd flavor.” But Sam’s Club itself isn’t a write-off when it comes to purchasing large quantities of mustard. Consumers can purchase other name brands in large two-pack bottles, a jug that weighs over 6 pounds, and a 500-count box of individual packets. Even if you have room left over in one of their oversized shopping carts, this mustard can be left on one of the seemingly endless store shelves.
There are no strange ingredients used; all are within the scope of a regular yellow mustard recipe such as spices like paprika and turmeric. However, reviewer Wizhat2 gave it a one-star rating. They claim to have tried various mustards before, including generic, and have concluded that this one has an “odd flavor.”
But Sam’s Club itself isn’t a write-off when it comes to purchasing large quantities of mustard. Consumers can purchase other name brands in large two-pack bottles, a jug that weighs over 6 pounds, and a 500-count box of individual packets. Even if you have room left over in one of their oversized shopping carts, this mustard can be left on one of the seemingly endless store shelves.
16. Trader Joe’s Dijon Mustard
Dijon mustard came to be in France in the 18th century and has been a delicacy in the country ever since. Named for the town of Dijon, this mustard has a distinct flavor profile from the standard American yellow mustard. Dijon uses both black and brown mustard seeds, but the most significant difference is that it doesn’t traditionally use vinegar. Instead, Dijon is made with verjuice, the liquid of unripened grapes, which gives it a smooth flavor, velvety texture, and thickened consistency. White wine is a popular substitute for verjuice, while some recipes use a mix of vinegar and spices.
Trader Joe’s has their own version of Dijon mustard, but unfortunately it’s not that much to be desired. The primary complaint is that it’s much too strong. A reviewer named Carol on Traderjoesreviews.com complains that it’s “like eating wasabi straight up,” a sentiment echoed by others on the site. Another reviewer claims that it gave them “stomach problems after eating it just once.”
Trader Joe’s has their own version of Dijon mustard, but unfortunately it’s not that much to be desired. The primary complaint is that it’s much too strong. A reviewer named Carol on Traderjoesreviews.com complains that it’s “like eating wasabi straight up,” a sentiment echoed by others on the site. Another reviewer claims that it gave them “stomach problems after eating it just once.”
15. Market Pantry Spicy Brown Mustard
Target
Spicy brown mustard gets its bite by soaking the mustard seeds in less vinegar during the preparation process. This means that the mustard seeds (brown and black, normally) are truer to their original taste. A variety of spices, such as cinnamon or nutmeg, can be used for a more robust flavor, but that doesn’t seem to be the case for the Target-brand Market Pantry spicy brown mustard which falls short in the taste department.
The mustard is labeled as “zesty deli style,” which is another way to indicate the rich spiciness. None of the standard ingredients stand out that would lead one to believe this has an off taste, though one addition is simply labelled as “spices” which is obviously quite vague. Onion powder is another ingredient that might raise an eyebrow, but it still doesn’t pinpoint whatever the exact problem is. According to a reviewer on Target’s website, the “flavor is too harsh” and it tasted more like horseradish. Another notes that it’s “nothing special.” Have no fear, there are other spicy brown varieties on this list that stay true to the traditional zing.
The mustard is labeled as “zesty deli style,” which is another way to indicate the rich spiciness. None of the standard ingredients stand out that would lead one to believe this has an off taste, though one addition is simply labelled as “spices” which is obviously quite vague. Onion powder is another ingredient that might raise an eyebrow, but it still doesn’t pinpoint whatever the exact problem is. According to a reviewer on Target’s website, the “flavor is too harsh” and it tasted more like horseradish. Another notes that it’s “nothing special.” Have no fear, there are other spicy brown varieties on this list that stay true to the traditional zing.
14. Annie’s Organic Yellow Mustard
Annie’s is a brand that is well-appreciated for their commitment to nurturing a healthy planet and healthy diets with their line of organic food products, which include vegan and gluten-free options. You may have noticed their macaroni and cheese, snacks, and baking items on your local grocery store shelves, but did you know that they produce dressings and condiments too? Annie’s currently offers four varieties of mustard, including a classic yellow.
They claim that their product is free from artificial flavorings and colors, and they strictly use all organic ingredients. So far, so good. While there are plenty of favorable consumer reviews for the mustard, it also has some detractors. KarinaGof on iHerb.com writes that it tastes sour, and several others agree on the weird taste. Another iHerb customer claims that it might just be “tinted mayonnaise without taste.” For this organic yellow mustard, it’s best not to let the positive reviews sway you until you try it for yourself.
They claim that their product is free from artificial flavorings and colors, and they strictly use all organic ingredients. So far, so good. While there are plenty of favorable consumer reviews for the mustard, it also has some detractors. KarinaGof on iHerb.com writes that it tastes sour, and several others agree on the weird taste. Another iHerb customer claims that it might just be “tinted mayonnaise without taste.” For this organic yellow mustard, it’s best not to let the positive reviews sway you until you try it for yourself.
13. Burman’s Spicy Brown Mustard
Aldi is a unique grocery store that began in Germany and has since spread worldwide. It first came here in 1976 and now has a dedicated Stateside following. Fans appreciate the chain’s low prices for staple foods like meats, breads, and frozen items. You won’t normally find too many name-brand products on their shelves, as Aldi’s inventory is stocked with over 90% of their own private brands such as Burman’s which specializes in condiments.
Their spicy brown mustard currently costs only $0.99, according to Instacart. It’s made with the usual distilled vinegar, mustard seeds, and spices found in any regular mustard, so what could be so wrong? Actually, not much. As far as discount mustards go, Aldi’s Burman’s brand isn’t too bad. Fooducate gives it an “A” rating, but watch out for 80 milligrams of sodium, which is slightly higher per serving (one teaspoon) compared to other brands. For that reason, we placed this in the middle of our list.
Their spicy brown mustard currently costs only $0.99, according to Instacart. It’s made with the usual distilled vinegar, mustard seeds, and spices found in any regular mustard, so what could be so wrong? Actually, not much. As far as discount mustards go, Aldi’s Burman’s brand isn’t too bad. Fooducate gives it an “A” rating, but watch out for 80 milligrams of sodium, which is slightly higher per serving (one teaspoon) compared to other brands. For that reason, we placed this in the middle of our list.
12. Colman’s Mustard
11. Bertman Original Ball Park Mustard
Since 1925, Bertman has manufactured their brown mustard out of Cleveland, Ohio and it has become not just a staple there, but at arenas and stadiums across the United States. In a head-to-head taste test with the other most famous ball park mustard, Stadium Mustard, Bertman’s Original just narrowly takes top billing.
10. Boar’s Head Delicatessen Style Mustard
9. Great Value Yellow Mustard
Great Value is the Walmart generic brand name. They have pretty much every kind of product you can think of, including home goods, toiletries, cleaning supplies, and groceries. Their foods are hit-or-miss, meaning that sometimes one of their generic products is tasty but other times it might be better to spend a little extra for the name brand and the quality that comes with it. That being said, one Great Value food product you should consider trying is their yellow mustard.
Yes, seriously! According to Walmart’s website, there’s nothing abnormal within the ingredients — mustard seed, vinegar, water, and some spices. There are zero calories and 60 milligrams of sodium per teaspoon, which is standard when it comes to the tangy condiment. Plus, a 20-ounce bottle will set you back a mere dollar. Now that’s a deal! Reviewer Marbelva claims that Great Value yellow mustard is “as good as French’s.” Over on Influenster, the reviews are also positive with Teresa G. suggesting it has the “same taste as name brands.” All in all, don’t devalue Great Value, at least when it comes to mustard.
Yes, seriously! According to Walmart’s website, there’s nothing abnormal within the ingredients — mustard seed, vinegar, water, and some spices. There are zero calories and 60 milligrams of sodium per teaspoon, which is standard when it comes to the tangy condiment. Plus, a 20-ounce bottle will set you back a mere dollar. Now that’s a deal!
Reviewer Marbelva claims that Great Value yellow mustard is “as good as French’s.” Over on Influenster, the reviews are also positive with Teresa G. suggesting it has the “same taste as name brands.” All in all, don’t devalue Great Value, at least when it comes to mustard.
8. Original Mister Mustard
7. Plochman’s Kosciusko Spicy Brown Mustard
6. Inglehoffer Original Stone Ground Mustard
5. Sir Kensington’s Spicy Brown Mustard
4. Grey Poupon Dijon Mustard
3. Heinz 100% Natural Yellow Mustard
Heinz is a beloved homegrown condiment company that dates back to 1869. Most famous for their tomato ketchup, they’ve grown into a world-leader in condiments ranging from pickles, mayonnaise, gravy, vinegar, and most recently a line of unique mixed sauces. When it comes to basic mustard, Heinz 100% natural yellow mustard is one of the very best. It’s a classic! Made with all natural ingredients, the strikingly bright yellow condiment provides a burst of zesty zing to your favorite meats, sandwiches, and sauces. And the best part? Zero calories, zero sugar, and zero sodium.
Influenster reviews are overwhelmingly positive with a near perfect rating based on over 900 reviews. It’s also listed as their second choice of mustards overall. Consumer Maika R. writes that this mustard matches the high quality that one would expect from Heinz food products. Melissa C. claims that “you can not go wrong” with Heinz’s yellow mustard, especially for the affordable price.
Influenster reviews are overwhelmingly positive with a near perfect rating based on over 900 reviews. It’s also listed as their second choice of mustards overall. Consumer Maika R. writes that this mustard matches the high quality that one would expect from Heinz food products. Melissa C. claims that “you can not go wrong” with Heinz’s yellow mustard, especially for the affordable price.
2. Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard
For the very best in spicy brown mustard zest, Gulden’s is the one to choose. Produced with organic vinegar, #1 grade mustard seeds, and an aromatic array of spices, Gulden’s Spicy Brown mustard is difficult to beat. Not only does it use fine, organic ingredients, it also contains less sodium than many of its competitors (just 50 milligrams per teaspoon).
While Influenster ranks it seventh on their mustard list, consumers over there give it a strong 4.8 out of 5-star rating. For reviewer Laura K., it’s the “only mustard” they buy. Maria V. suggests using it in vegetable soup to “kick up the flavor,” as well as adding some to egg dishes and squeezed on top of hot dogs. Various other reviews state that Gulden’s isn’t too spicy, which can make it appealing to most taste buds, and thus ranks it as one of the leading mustards that is currently available.
While Influenster ranks it seventh on their mustard list, consumers over there give it a strong 4.8 out of 5-star rating. For reviewer Laura K., it’s the “only mustard” they buy. Maria V. suggests using it in vegetable soup to “kick up the flavor,” as well as adding some to egg dishes and squeezed on top of hot dogs. Various other reviews state that Gulden’s isn’t too spicy, which can make it appealing to most taste buds, and thus ranks it as one of the leading mustards that is currently available.
1. French’s Classic Yellow Mustard
Mustard in its natural form is derived from the mustard seed, which can be beneficial for your health. However, in processed condiment form, it’s French’s Classic Yellow that is the most beneficial on burgers and hot dogs. And classic it is, ever since French’s debuted at the 1904 World’s Fair. It quickly became an American favorite, whether you were at a baseball game or a local backyard barbecue. Although they provide a plethora of condiments and other food products including Crispy Fried Onions and chili seasonings, the name French’s has become synonymous with yellow mustard.
It holds a steady 4.9 out of 5-rating with 97% of reviewers recommending the bright yellow product, via McCormick’s website. Influenster ranks it as their top mustard (with over 7,000 consumer reviews) and rightfully so. Ginger L. suggests adding it to chicken and egg salads, and praises the top quality for the value. Erin H. calls it the “best yellow mustard out there” and contends that it’s the only one to buy, claiming that it tastes better than store-branded varieties. They also rave that the consistency is just right and the squeeze bottle provides the perfect portion, along with the ideal tang, of course. French’s mustard just can’t be beat.
It holds a steady 4.9 out of 5-rating with 97% of reviewers recommending the bright yellow product, via McCormick’s website. Influenster ranks it as their top mustard (with over 7,000 consumer reviews) and rightfully so. Ginger L. suggests adding it to chicken and egg salads, and praises the top quality for the value. Erin H. calls it the “best yellow mustard out there” and contends that it’s the only one to buy, claiming that it tastes better than store-branded varieties. They also rave that the consistency is just right and the squeeze bottle provides the perfect portion, along with the ideal tang, of course. French’s mustard just can’t be beat.
